Interesting question
Sep. 15th, 2007 05:35 pmI was reading something that asked this, and I found it a rather interesting question. So I am asking you folks about it.
Which setting would you rather live in; Star Trek, or Star Wars?
Now, I'm not asking if you'd rather command a Federation star ship or pilot an X-wing, that's a different question entirely. I'm asking if you'd rather be an ordinary citizen of the Empire and the later restored Republic, or of the Federation. Assuming you stay yourself, keep your skills in more or less the same area, adjusted to fit the local tech base, which place would you prefer?
Interesting thought, isn't it? Because on an entertainment level, I prefer Star Wars, even with the massive drop in quality in recent years, to Star Trek. But when it comes to realistically considering the settings, I find Star Trek to be both easier to relate to, and more appealing to live in. Star Wars is essentially feudal. If you're not a ruler of some sort, you're a peasant, a non-entity. (Did you know that even Han Solo is supposed to be descended from some ruling family or other?) Star Trek is much more democratic and egalitarian, so since I'm hardly likely to become a princess or president, I'd rather live there.
Which setting would you rather live in; Star Trek, or Star Wars?
Now, I'm not asking if you'd rather command a Federation star ship or pilot an X-wing, that's a different question entirely. I'm asking if you'd rather be an ordinary citizen of the Empire and the later restored Republic, or of the Federation. Assuming you stay yourself, keep your skills in more or less the same area, adjusted to fit the local tech base, which place would you prefer?
Interesting thought, isn't it? Because on an entertainment level, I prefer Star Wars, even with the massive drop in quality in recent years, to Star Trek. But when it comes to realistically considering the settings, I find Star Trek to be both easier to relate to, and more appealing to live in. Star Wars is essentially feudal. If you're not a ruler of some sort, you're a peasant, a non-entity. (Did you know that even Han Solo is supposed to be descended from some ruling family or other?) Star Trek is much more democratic and egalitarian, so since I'm hardly likely to become a princess or president, I'd rather live there.